Sativen, on this one I think that the glow or reflection on the back of the glass above the liquid is cool, but the rest of the image suffers. I think that it looks like the glass spilled on the background, and this is distracting, the back-lighting makes the drink look 'skunky' like I would need to skim that stuff off of the top, and the liquid highlights seem blown (posterized). I also don't think that the border is doing anything for the image, and as I said on the other image it looks like the drink has been sitting out. Of the two the other image is better, but I am not sure that either accomplished their goals, but that is really for you to decide. In my opinion, if you are doing a set up shot like this then everything has (HAS) to be perfect, that is why it is setup. Chris
