photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Dave Beedon | all galleries >> Hiking Handcart >> First Handcart Hike > Lazy man's way of hauling "too much stuff"
previous | next
9 June 2013 20110609_3355

Lazy man's way of hauling "too much stuff"

Crater Island, Utah (26 mi./ 42 km northeast of Wendover) view map


I'm standing on the mud flat that surrounds Crater Island, Utah (30 miles northeast of Wendover), pulling a home-made handcart loaded with my camping gear.

My smile is a put-on. In truth, I was miserable. The mud was too wet and soft, making forward progress very difficult, illustrated better in two other photos. After two miles of suffering from gummed up tires, I realized the futility of the exercise and returned to my campsite.

The handcart is basically a shallow box mounted on a smaller box. Attached to the underside of the smaller box is the axle and wheels of my hand truck. The long handles are 1x4s screwed to the upper box and dowels attached to them with U-bolts.

A home-made waist harness is attached to the box with black webbing so I could comfortably pull the cart, but it didn’t work. Walking while wearing the harness imparted a jerky pulling motion that was very annoying.

Equipment carried on the initial hike was a tent, sleeping bag, sleeping pad, ground sheet, camping chair, first aid kit, miscellaneous tools, camping stove, freeze-dried meals, sandwiches, energy bars, four gallons of water, and an inflated spare tire.

Joe Tripod, who accompanied me on this Trek from Hell, ignored my suffering to concentrate on his Motionless Mission on Mud. Geo-tagging is approximate.

Two weeks later I repeated the hike with two changes to the design: I left the waist harness at home and added a crossbar at the ends of the handles. Both changes made pulling or pushing the cart much easier. I was surprised to learn that pushing---with the cart in front of me---was easier than pulling it.


Nikon D80
1/160s f/18.0 at 36.0mm iso200 full exif

other sizes: small medium original auto
share
Dave Beedon08-Mar-2015 20:41
It was a surprise to find out that I enjoyed pushing more
than pulling. I had assumed that pulling---especially if
done from the hips---would be much easier. The jerking
of the strap arrangement was awful and so I abandoned
it without ever trying a system in which the handles
were connected directly to the hipbelt.

My preference for pushing is solely a matter of comfort.
It has nothing to do with the quality of the surface of the
mud or with avoiding obstacles. Pushing might very well
use more energy, but it feels better to me.

My affinity for pushing is demonstrated by my most
recent cart design: http://www.pbase.com/listorama/image/152286815
Eric Palmer 07-Mar-2015 04:08
Very interested in your experience. I don't doubt your report, but your statement that pushing was easier than pulling contradicts the physics. Something other than physics must have been at work. Can you analyze exactly why pushing was easier? (Ability to see/anticipate obstacles? Tendency to use the crossbar more (less use of arm strength, more with the legs)? Tendency to use the crossbar less (reducing the jerky motion with each step)?
Dave Beedon23-Jul-2011 06:43
exzim is trying to muddy the waters with his comment. I hope viewers will take it with a grain of salt, as it originates in Toronto, Canada (a place where the salt comes from trucks rather than from the ground).
exzim22-Jul-2011 21:52
Viewers of this picture need to be warned. This is not Crater Island, Utah. It is a picture of downtown Listorama park in Notner, which occupies the same city centre position as does Central Park in NYC. Another alien trick exposed
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment