photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment
ctfchallenge | all galleries >> Challenge #7: Portraits In Black and White (or Sepia) >> Critique Gallery > Johannes's no(i)se
previous | next
06-APR-2002 Willie G (effzee)

Johannes's no(i)se

Bad Berneck, Germany

This looked terrible in color, though I think the noise works well in B/W.
Opinions?

Canon PowerShot G2
1/15s f/2.5 at 21.0mm (35mm equivalent: 106mm) full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
comment | share
Guest 12-Apr-2002 20:13
Thank you for the comments :o)
The graininess (noise) was, um, natural. My camera did it. I called it Johanne's no(i)se just for fun. Get it? Nose/Noise... ah forget it, lol.
ctfchallenge11-Apr-2002 18:46
I agree with the previous post that I don't think the nose is really all that emphasized. I'm much more drawn to his eyes, which I like greatly. The "negative space" on the left is interesting, but it could be smaller. I don't mind the cropping, but I think the photo feels a bit unbalanced. I think maybe I'd try cropping it into a square and seeing how you like the results. I like the (applied?) grainyness though. It definitely matches with his angular features and the way that he's looking at the camera (if that makes any sense at all).
cgesteland 11-Apr-2002 16:00
This shot grabbed my eye right away, yet it seems like something's missing... Hmm. The title indicates that you are trying to emphasize his nose. I don't know that that's conveyed very clearly here. The immense gray space on the left side detracts attention and though I tend to favor partial facial portraits, having the chin cut from the frame just makes it look like you should have turned your camera 90 degrees and given him a vertical frame.

He is certainly an arresting subject with eyes that skewer the viewer. Cropping the left side and maybe the mouth would be a better way to go... It's a tough one. Gee, was my wishy-washy advice a lot of help? ;)