Wendy
I think I almost like this the best. So simple and elegant lines. The shading on the vases, I don't usually like selective coloring much (so many use it for emphasis rather than as a compositional element), but this is superb...and adds so much to the balance of the composition. The detail in the arch...The framing with the vine. I do think I like this one best...you've made it so hard to decide...there are so many to like.
Barri