Carole I think you have truly done your homework here. Rather complex comp here and I think you're toying with my rating system (not that you really had any idea what it was esp since I still don't.) But this starts off with an 8 for all corners and edges engaged in the comp without a serious center violation. However, the two right corners seem to have sacrificed some weight in favor of a fabulous right edge impact. I'll have to deduct .1 from each corner but add .2 to the included edge. Still an 8. Nice work. -tv