photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Canon DSLR Challenge | all galleries >> Canon SLR Challenges - FAQ >> CSLR - Best of... >> Best of 2005 > Track West *
1st Place
previous | next
08-JUL-2005 Jim H.

Track West *
1st Place


other sizes: small medium original auto
share
jypsee17-Jul-2005 20:28
Processing a digital photo is not "cheating" or corrupting the photograph. It's no different than darkroom manipulation. I like the off kilter feel of this photo, tilted horizon and all. I especially like the reflection in the rail.
ctfchallenge13-Jul-2005 23:54
I'm really torn about this one. I look at it and think this is supposed to be a really good shot, yet something about it is really bugging me. Maybe the tilted horizon? Maybe the overprocessing of the soil? Ok, I think maybe that it's such a nice natural shot, but it's been overprocessed which gives it an artificial feel. I bet the original, with a slightly bumped up saturation would be much nicer. Sorry, Jim, nothing personal, I just tend to be extremely critical. Not that I could do any better, though I love to be able to. :) The concept is absolutely excellent, though. It was very well seen. I'm sure it's just the processing; I'm normally no prude when it comes to processing - I've got nothing against that and do plenty myself. ~ Lonnit
Guest 13-Jul-2005 22:31
Gosh this is good, but it need just a bit of CW rotation to get the horizon level.
Mikel Featherston13-Jul-2005 17:02
Stunning image.
Canon DSLR Challenge13-Jul-2005 12:01
Absolutely gorgeous! Not much more to say...but it got my vote in the booth.
Gayle
Canon DSLR Challenge13-Jul-2005 08:14
Wonderful photograph,

Hope you had a team of spotters watching your back :D

Tom (BBKVale)
Canon DSLR Challenge13-Jul-2005 02:11
Just great! The reflection and color in the rail is very creative. Nice job. My only critique might be that the mud on either side seems a little overly processed. Still, marvelous. -- Bruce
Canon DSLR Challenge13-Jul-2005 01:18
Sigh...you're right, Rob, this is just about as good as a picture gets. Traveller
Canon DSLR Challenge13-Jul-2005 00:10
stunning!

Rob