photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
stealthfti | profile | all galleries >> Galleries >> to find some good aluminum tree view | thumbnails | slideshow

to find some good aluminum

As a part of the Sarah Project B230FT engine, the cylinder head had to be right. What I had thought to be a fairly straightforward and routine part of the engine building project turned out to be considerably more involved.

The first two cylinder heads that I examined for the rebuild were not in the condition that I had expected. The problems I found with those two heads forced me to examine more cylinder heads to find one good enough for the engine. I went through eleven cylinder heads to come up with three candidates. I used the best of the three.

While examining all these cylinder heads, I came to some conclusions as to what the problems were and could be; the causes of those problems; and what I would need to do in order to not have those problems.

The Volvo SOHC [single overhead camshaft] cylinder head is, in my opinion, one of the best, if not THE best, cylinder head designs ever. I was fairly convinced of that before I started this engine project. The examinations, analyses, and determinations of the problems and solutions to those problems did not change my opinion of the SOHC head: it strengthened that opinion.

I consider the volvo SOHC head an excellent design because it is a very efficient package:
...it performs all its tasks with a minimum number of moving parts: the valvetrain is designed to operate smoothly and without rocker arms or followers...fewer moving parts to wear out...less weight for the valve springs to control;
...those parts are configured to operate in the minimum space needed: very compact and tidy;
...the valvetrain components that must endure high pressure loads are well lubricated;
...the tappet design protects the valve stems and guides from any side load: the valves only have to go up and down; any sideload from the cam lobes are absorbed by the well lubricated and well supported bucket type tappets;
...the layout of each cylinder's ports, runners, and combustion chambers is uniform: no mirroring; no reversed configuration;
...swirl is promoted by the inline valve arrangement and the intake ports being tangential to the centerline;
...All of this is done and contained in a single casting....an intricate yet very straightforward design; laid out like a four floor production facility: everything in its place; and a place for every necessary thing.

Are there more "modern" head designs out there? Certainly. And I guess that the general attitude is that 'newer' has to be 'better'. That is not always the case. Excellence and quality are timeless; change for the sake of change is not the correct foundational motivation. Change should be based on the desire for, and with the goal of, improvement.

I have long believed that to remove material from the deck surface in amounts greater than the absolute minimum needed to restore flatness was not wise; whether the head be iron or aluminum. As a result of this forced, but not unwelcomed or regretted, excercise and investigation; my bias against such material removal has only intensified: to "shave a head" to raise compression ratio, especially on an aluminum head, is very ill-advised; and to do that on an aluminum head used in a boosted motor is, as I have come to see things, a very stupid and counterproductive idea....if you are concerned with longevity and durability.

This gallery will follow my search; show some of the problems I found; my conclusions regarding the causes and solutions; and will illustrate some of what I decided to do to address, correct, and avoid them.

UPDATE:
Last year I did a gallery on 'Headbolts', and made it a subgallery here. It seemed to fit in with this gallery. I decided to make 'Headbolts' a separate gallery; to assist those viewing the main page to find that information.

For those arriving here from a link to see the headbolt information, it is the gallery following this one.
the desired result:  a B23OFT head (almost) ready to go
the desired result: a B23OFT head (almost) ready to go
the UNDESIRED result....1st view
the UNDESIRED result....1st view
the undesired result....a 2nd view
the undesired result....a 2nd view
A close up view
A close up view
zeroing in on the real cause...view 1
zeroing in on the real cause...view 1
zeroing in...view 2
zeroing in...view 2
the three problems.....close up
the three problems.....close up
finding out more...
finding out more...
closing in...
closing in...
the source of the failure...
the source of the failure...
confirmation
confirmation
starting the list of what to look for...
starting the list of what to look for...
I want one unsurfaced...
I want one unsurfaced...
I want the cam journals to be aligned...
I want the cam journals to be aligned...
No Cracks Please...
No Cracks Please...
some helpful glare
some helpful glare
from a different angle:  yes; it is still there
from a different angle: yes; it is still there
Why cracks are bad...
Why cracks are bad...
some fade correction to show the seats rising
some fade correction to show the seats rising
formulating  the plan...
formulating the plan...
exhaust port short side radius outside shelf
exhaust port short side radius outside shelf
exhaust port short side radius inside shelf
exhaust port short side radius inside shelf
intake port short side radius inside shelf
intake port short side radius inside shelf
intake port bowl...the shelf is very evident
intake port bowl...the shelf is very evident