photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Forty One: Ruins and wrecks: photographing the rusted, busted past > Bordello, Gold King Mine, Haynes, Arizona, 2007
previous | next
06-AUG-2007

Bordello, Gold King Mine, Haynes, Arizona, 2007

Black and white can add a powerful sense of poignancy to an image, particularly images out of the past. In color, this image does a beautiful job of vividly describing the ruins of a bordello that once served the miners who worked this mine in the early 20th century. Built high on a hill, it can only be viewed at a distance, and the painted mannequin in a white dress dominated the original color version of this image. When I zoomed in on the mannequin, important details show up for the first time, such as its incongruously missing hand and mournful expression. But the painted face of the mannequin looked very artificial in color. I changed it to a sepia image, but the graphic effect looked contrived. When I converted it to black and white, the color details on the painted face vanished, the porch looked older, and the mannequin became more of a ghost, and less of a whore. In black and white, the vandalized mannequin personifies the death of the Old West.

Leica V-Lux 1
1/400s f/6.3 at 71.0mm iso100 hide exif
Full EXIF Info
Date/Time06-Aug-2007 11:48:01
MakeLeica
ModelV-LUX 1
Flash UsedNo
Focal Length71 mm
Exposure Time1/400 sec
Aperturef/6.3
ISO Equivalent100
Exposure Bias-0.66
White Balance
Metering Modemulti spot (3)
JPEG Quality
Exposure Programprogram (2)
Focus Distance

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis16-Nov-2007 23:58
You reinforce my point here eloquently, Lynn. I had the same feeling about this image in color that you must have had towards your cemetery photographs. It was too pretty and too real in color. Black and white makes the image timeless, and both of us were dealing with time as a subject. Thanks for the comment.
LynnH16-Nov-2007 20:38
Very nice. I understand what you said about changing your image to black and white. I recently posted some New Orleans cemetary photos on PBase. I had tinkered with them, but could never get the right mood. Once I changed them to black and white, I could SEE what I had FELT when I was taking the shots. Thanks for sharing!
Phil Douglis26-Sep-2007 23:20
Context is everything in photography, Christine. We can add it or subtract it at will, thereby changing the intent and message of the image. Thanks for your comment, as always.
Christine P. Newman26-Sep-2007 21:47
I recognize this one well. I had taken a photo of this lady in avery different light - mine looked like a doll, taken out of context. Yours tells us a different story.
Phil Douglis19-Aug-2007 18:17
Thanks, Jenene, for your musings on this image and your thoughts on prostitution in the Old West. I had hoped this image would do just that. We cloak the Old West in a romantic patina, but its mining camps were sordid and often lawless places. The unfortunate women who worked in them paid a terrible price for the few dollars they earned. Not only is this image a study of a ruined place, it is also a study of ruined lives.
JSWaters19-Aug-2007 03:39
My mind doesn't take me as far as Cecilia's, but I'm still left pondering the circumstances that brought that woman to this particular place? Her costume is so out of place amidst the roughly hewn wood banister. I know it's a mannequin, and it's been ravaged by time, but it's got me thinking about the women who let the men working this mine ravage them for money, and if they were there of their own free will, what did they get out of it?
Jenene
Phil Douglis16-Aug-2007 23:02
Thanks, as always, Ceci, for bringing an entirely different point of view to bear on this image. You have turned it, a usual, into a thought provoking piece of social commentary. I can see how you would interpret it this way -- we still live in a world where criminals not only exploit women in this way, but in many places have virtually enslaved them. Thank you for putting this focus on it. I hope that it might also raise consciousness on this issue, as you say.
Guest 16-Aug-2007 22:35
The vandalized figure might symbolize the death of the Old West, but it also (to me) symbolizes the fact that prostitution is alive and well all around the globe -- a form of often enforced and brutal bondage, mostly for girls and women. Your BW mannequin captures for me the ruination and degradation of woman in a most powerful way, with her haunted expression, ragged clothing and the way she's leaning on the worn ballustrade, as if unable to stand upright on her own. There are so many females sold into abusive slavery -- often as children -- that this photograph can also be taken as a symbol of their imprisonment, and thus a way to raise consciousness about it. That missing hand could also be a metaphor for the punishments meted out to those who try and escape this insidious system. A really strong picture, Phil!
Phil Douglis15-Aug-2007 16:33
Thanks, Mo, for seeing the value of the medium itself here. Black and white does three things here -- it abstracts the image to stress the essence of it, it replicates the kind of image that might have been made of this scene back in the early 20th century, and it makes meaning universally ghostly instead of specifically descriptive, by removing all the specifics such as color and much of the detail that comes with it. You are right -- it makes time stand still as it evokes the past.
monique jansen15-Aug-2007 06:32
Timeless. Black and white really makes this photo dramatic, evoking the past well
Phil Douglis13-Aug-2007 22:39
Thanks, Kal. As I noted in the caption, the black and white renders the mannequin more ghostly than whorish. And yes, this image is all about making time stand still through ghostly expression. It could just have well have been placed in either my black and white gallery, or my gallery on the camera as time machine. But it works just as well as an insight into this wreck and ruin of a place.
Kal Khogali13-Aug-2007 21:09
Ghostly is what I fealt here. The choice of B&W was an excellent chice to create that feeling of time standing still. A powerful image telling the story of time, trough spirit. K
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment