photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Thirteen: Bringing Fresh Visions to Tired Clichés > Hidalgo Plaza, Tecate, Mexico, 2004
previous | next
18-APR-2004

Hidalgo Plaza, Tecate, Mexico, 2004

In the center of the small Mexican border town of Tecate, there is a well-kept Plaza surrounding a bandstand. Wrought iron benches encircle the bandstand, occupied at mid-day by Tecate residents who chat with their friends, relax in the sun, or nod off to sleep. Photographing such a place as this is really a form of “street photography,” another major source of travel picture clichés. Most street scenes are chaotic, jumbled renderings of people walking down a street. To bring fresh vision to bear on street photographs, we must find ways to simplify the structure of the picture so that the body language of the subjects is clearly defined and without distraction. When I brought my cameras to bear on Tecate’s Hidalgo Plaza, I searched for a simple background, and found it in the stone base of the bandstand and in the shadows surrounding it. This backdrop gives precedence to the bench sitters in the foreground and to the large open area in front of them. Using a 24mm wide-angle converter lens, I moved in on the fellow sitting on the bench in the foreground, and shot him for a while, using his body language as the anchor for my images. Eventually someone else wearing a western hat came by, and when he did, I photographed this scene as he and his shadow slip away from the man on the bench – leaving him alone. And that’s what this picture is about - loneliness. I would like to know what the man sitting before us might be thinking at this moment, and where the other fellow may be heading. This image is strong enough to ask such questions of its viewers, taking it out of the realm of cliché photos.

Canon PowerShot G5
1/1250s f/6.3 at 7.2mm full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis03-Apr-2005 04:16
Glad you like this one, Benchang. The hats do add context for locale. I know you are learning hard, and so far I am able to stay right up with you. Not because I have to, but because I can, and I want to. It is not hard for me right now to respond promptly. I've got some time to do so. When I don't have that time, you may not hear from me for a while. But you will hear from me eventually. No substantive comment in my cyberbook ever goes unanswered.
Benchang Tang 03-Apr-2005 03:55
I just love this photo. The two caps really tell me the locatin. I actually am going along the lessons and am learning hard. I noticed you always comment on my ideas promptly, and that is hard for you. I hope you can come to the the classroom once a week.
Thank you again.
Phil Douglis02-Nov-2004 05:36
Thank you, Maureen, for appreciating my attempt to make form serve content here.
Guest 02-Nov-2004 04:04
Phil, I wasn't sure if you had purposely shot this way, or not. Now that you've explained your intention, I totally agree that you captured this exactly the way you should have. I like it that much more. Thanks for the reply!
Phil Douglis31-Oct-2004 19:49
I am always thrilled when you are willing to be critical of my images, Maureen, because you give me an opportunity to explain my reasons for doing things in my pictures that might well be useful to you. Read them over, re-evaluate the image, and let me know if you can see the image in a different light (pin intended.)

Yes, the dark shadow, bronze statue effect was intentional, Maureen. I use light here as abstraction. By removing detail, I intend to make these people symbolic, less individualistic, less real, and more representative of us all. If I had chosen to use evaluative, instead of spot, metering, more detail would come up, the people would look more naturl, the colors in the Plaza would be less intense and perhaps even slightly burned out and the image would become, in my view anyway, less symbolic and more literal.

Given this reasoning, are you still distracted by my abstraction, Maureen. If so, how you would have conveyed the same idea by adding more detail in those shadows?
Guest 31-Oct-2004 16:54
I really like what this photograph conveys, but I'm distracted by the fact that anything that isn't in direct sunlight has lost all detail. The darks are too dark. For all I know, these aren't even real people, they could be bronze statues. Was this intentional?
Phil Douglis22-Oct-2004 02:07
You are wonderful, Zebra! You've made me, and anyone else who stops by this example, look at this picture in a fresh, new way. You have ingeniously broken the image down into its structure in terms of its prime color, and then linked that color into a pattern of meaning unto itself. Thank you, my friend, for pointing this out.
Phil
Phil Douglis22-Oct-2004 01:15
Thanks, Rod, for this nice comment. It's an honor for me to be dubbed your "professor" even though my "doctorate" in photographic expression comes from 35 years of teaching others how to communicate, as opposed to an adanced degree. Theoretically, your idea for improving this shot makes a lot of sense. I, too, would have loved longer shadows to give a greater sense of departure to the man at right, but the sun was high in the sky which shortens shadows rather than lengthens them. If I had changed my vantage point, I would have lost the horizontal thrust of that bench which anchors the picture. Every image, if carefully thought through will have its share of successes, and shortcomings as well. That's the nature of photography.
Guest 21-Oct-2004 22:00
I can find out four "caps" in this photo.Two caps on cowboys' heads,and the roof is the third cap.These three caps make up of a nice triangle,(if the man did not go away,the triangle would not be formed.) and they are all in the middle of the forth cap,the round floor.The sunshine gave these caps strong contrast and beautiful arc.I love sunshine for ever!
Phil,do you agree with my comment? I love this four-caps-photo .
Guest 14-Oct-2004 23:53
Phil, you can be my professor. :) This photo cleary gives the sense of the standing cowboy leaving the seated one. But, I do wonder if it would not be even powerful it it was taken at a slightly different angle, so their shadows will come into play even more (slightly longer, as the shadows will not come directly into you, but rahter more at an angle? I think it would add even more abstraction).
Phil Douglis15-Aug-2004 15:48
Jen,

In very few words, you have given us an accurate summary of how to approach street photography-- that ebb and flow of human interaction as it occurs in public places. You have obviously absorbed the lessons I intended to this picture to offer you, Jen. Now harness these concepts to your considerable instincts for humanistic photography, and make images that full express the vitality and meaning you find on the streets of Shanghai, Jen. Thanks as usual for another valuable contribution.
Phil
Jennifer Zhou15-Aug-2004 14:08
This lesson tells me that street photography is nothing like we go out on the street and simply take the picture. A good street photograph need as Lara and Anna have just learned: to bring out questions and to isolate the subject. What more I learned is that street photogrpahy needs careful observation, to study the subject and to emphasize the interest point. Spending time there until everything comes to the right place for the picture, and then take the shot! That moment is not longer a kind of luck(as some peope said street photography is largely depend on luck), it is all about hard work. Am I right teacher?
Phil Douglis27-Jul-2004 16:36
Wonderful point, Anna. Clutter is a huge problem, not only in street photography but in all aspects of photography. We can isolate our subjects through the vantage points we choose -- which affects our framing, and the subject's relationship to its background. We also can use abstraction to isolate our subjects by working with the shadows, such as I do here, soft focus, and much closer vantage points. Moving in on our subjects is particularly important in wideangle photographs such as this one -- otherwise our pictures would fall apart.

And thanks, too, Anna, for your kind comment on my "photography course." I've posted this multi-gallery "cyberbook" on expressive travel photography to help passionate photographers such as yourself gradually become more selective, emphatic, and above all, more effective as a communicator. You are one of my favorite students, because you obviously recognize the value of the ideas I illustrate in these galleries, and you are beginning to put them to work in your images. Keep it up!
Anna Yu27-Jul-2004 03:53
Yes, the trouble with street photography is too MANY people in one place, with a jumble of directions and faces. Like the jumble of a big bunch of flowers in a vase. Isolation of the subject will be my lesson for today. Thank you Phil, this is a GREAT photography course!
Phil Douglis08-Jul-2004 17:40
Thanks, Lara. You responded to this image exactly as I hoped you would. This photograph is designed to ask questions and demand answers from the viewer. I took it to seize your imagination. And that's what expressive photography is all about.
Lara S08-Jul-2004 02:44
yes the way you've positioned this photo, it does look to me that he's just gotten up and is walking away, Makes me wonder what happened, what was exhanged? where he's going?
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment