photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Five: Using the frame to define ideas > Tet visitors, Hanoi, Vietnam, 2000
previous | next
25-FEB-2000

Tet visitors, Hanoi, Vietnam, 2000

Masses of visitors approach Hanoi's Temple of Literature at Tet, the Chinese New Year. Although there are actually less than twenty five people in this picture, their placement in the frame implies that there are many more than that. They flow towards me, and then seem to continue beyond the confines of my image. This is largely because I have pushed both the bottom and right hand edges of my frame into the crowd to funnel it into the lower right corner. I leave no space around them except at left , which gives form to this long line of visitors.

Kodak DC4800
1/125s f/4.5 at 17.7mm full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis19-Jan-2008 04:17
I wish you had kept that image, Vera. What would history say if the photo editors at Life Magazine had thrown out Robert Capa's famous photo of a blurred American soldier trapped under fire on a D-Day beach. The lab dried his film too quickly and apparently had "ruined" all of his epic images, yet the editors had the good sense to forget what the word "ruined" meant and instead read the meaning of the blurred pictures. The whole story of that day is here:http://www.skylighters.org/photos/robertcapa.html
Phil Douglis04-Oct-2005 16:58
The population of Vietnam today is about 83 million people. It is growing at a rate of about two per cent a year. So back in 2001, it was probably around 77 million.
tyrinia 04-Oct-2005 06:43
what was the population then
Phil Douglis30-Sep-2005 15:55
The frame always can help us make less seem like more.
Guest 30-Sep-2005 14:01
This photo makes me think of the minds of the AP (associated press) photographers. I bet this is a technique they keep in mind when shooting demonstrations and rallies. Often it's hard to get a vantage point to shoot a huge scene, so they may use similar techniques shown here to give the illusion of masses being present. I'll definitely keep this in mind when I move to Indonesia next year (as they have big rallies during political events). :)
Phil Douglis25-Sep-2005 23:06
Thanks, Rod, for your observation.The frame here is an abstracting device. It show us less, yet implies more.
Guest 25-Sep-2005 20:14
Very well done, Phil. This photo surprised me. I was surprised to see there were far fewer individuals than I originally thought. The framing did it's job!
Phil Douglis31-Dec-2004 04:55
Thanks, Clara, for the thought. I agree with you -- this mass of people is perpetuating collective behavior. We call it a ritual. I think rituals such as this are essentially social gatherings -- people leaving home and getting together in public. And rituals such as this Vietnamese cultural pilgrimage are indeed sanctioned by society. Automatic behavior is safe behavior. Non controversial. It gives people something to do, yet keeps them out of trouble. And so they come, marching though my frame, a line that never seems to end.
Guest 30-Dec-2004 21:05
Cultural pilgrimage. I wonder to what extend humans we have made of cultural (and other kinds) pilgrimage a culture in itself, an automatic behaviour sanctioned by society.
Phil Douglis25-Mar-2004 20:04
The frame, Karen, is an abstracting device. Abstraction can stimulate the imaginations of our viewers. By showing less, we imply that there is much more. It's the imagination that provides the extra people here.
Karen Stuebing25-Mar-2004 11:16
Amazing. It really does look like there are hundreds of people lined up!
Phil Douglis09-Nov-2003 22:28
Thanks, Denise. This shot is one of my favorites as well. As for Tet, I am not sure if it exclusively Vietnamese or not. I do know there that are many Chinese in Vietnam -- we visited a number of Chinese temples while there.

Phil
Denise Dee09-Nov-2003 12:34
i love this shot. Tet is the Vietnamese New Year, is it also the Chinese? I know in S.F. the Vietnamese New Year usually came before the Chinese one. denise
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment