photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Joel | profile | all galleries >> sports >> Administration >> Other Images >> Canon L Series Lens Comparison tree view | thumbnails | slideshow

Canon L Series Lens Comparison

*** Update Jan. 26 - 70mm tests have been uploaded.

This gallery is street comparison of several popular Canon L series lenses:
Canon 17-40L f/4 @ 24mm, 35mm at f/4 and f/8
Canon 24-105L IS f/4 @ 24mm, 35mm, 70mm at f/4 and f/8
Canon 24-70L f2.8 @ 24mm, 35mm, 70mm at f/4 f/8
Canon 35L f/1.4 @ 35mm at f/4 and f/8
Canon 70-200L f/4 non-IS @ 70mm at f/4 and f/8
Canon 28-135IS f/3.5-5.6 @ 35mm, 70mm at f/4 and f/8

The intention of this test was to help me decide what lenses I should upgrade. Though I felt the 17-40L was a keeper and I had no intention of replacing this UWA lens, I felt I may be able to improve mid range zoom by replacing the 28-135IS. I currently do not have a good long zoom, so testing the 70-200L would give me first hand experience with this beautiful lens.
As I was testing rental lenses, I did not have the opportunity to find an ideal location. I had to settle on shots right in front of the store during a lunch hour. Regardless, I learned a lot during this test.

Some notes on the test. All shots were taken with a Canon 5D, tripod mounted with the mirror locked up to avoid any camera shake that may affect the results. As much as possible I tried to take the exact same shot with each focal length, though it was tough because I had to bring the camera back into the store to exchange lenses (though the tripod stayed in the same location). All shots were taken within 45 minutes of eachother. I used the camera's centered weighted average metering and the autofocus was set to the top right autofocus point which was around the middle of the hotel in the 24mm pictures. I felt this would help ensure consistency.

All images were captured as raw files. No processing was done against them aside from the obvious cropping. They are represented exactly how the sensor captured them.

I realize this isn't much in the way of a scientific test. That said, I tried to reduce the number of variables that otherwise might affect the results. Because there are so many questions regarding the sharpness or quality of these lenses and how they compare to each other, I decided to post these images (and their 100% crops) to help others in the same boat as me. Please keep in mind that this is just one comparison on one day. Even if certain images stood out for you, consider doing a similar test yourself and above all, try the lenses on your camera to get a good feel for ergonomics. I hope you find this test of some value when it comes to making a decision on your next purchase.
g4/57/44657/3/91902782.cBshldoU.jpg Canon 17-40 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 17-40 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f4 (warning: full size)
24mm f4 100% crops at centre
24mm f4 100% crops at centre
24mm f4 100% crops at top right
24mm f4 100% crops at top right
24mm f4 100% crops at bottom right
24mm f4 100% crops at bottom right
o4/57/44657/1/91901499.5k4QxfP8.fill1.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91901501.zyjRPUxT.fill2copy.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91905580.lMeDGLX5.fill1.jpg
g4/57/44657/3/91902784.buiXkIZD.jpg Canon 17-40 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 17-40 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f8 (warning: full size)
24mm f8 centre 100% crops at centre
24mm f8 centre 100% crops at centre
24mm f8 100% crops at top right
24mm f8 100% crops at top right
24mm f8 100% crops at bottom right
24mm f8 100% crops at bottom right
o4/57/44657/1/91901502.HnhAuhkX.fill3.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91902206.NESSvRPG.fill1.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91905583.AXcrbYvr.fill2copy.jpg
g4/57/44657/3/91902780.9JpAXazX.jpg Canon 17-40 24mm at f16 (warning: full size)
Canon 17-40 24mm at f16 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f16 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 24mm at f16 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f11(warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 24mm at f11(warning: full size)
24mm f16 100% crops at centre
24mm f16 100% crops at centre
24mm f16 100% crops at top right
24mm f16 100% crops at top right
24mm f16 100% crops at bottom right
24mm f16 100% crops at bottom right
o4/57/44657/1/91902209.NM1haLMV.fill2copy.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91902210.yhYiDDZx.fill3.jpg o4/57/44657/1/91905584.yxtbSAL8.fill3.jpg
g4/57/44657/3/91905324.vpI3XGil.jpg Canon 17-40 36mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 17-40 36mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 34mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 34mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 32mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 32mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 35L 35mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 35L 35mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 35mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 35mm at f4 (warning: full size)
35mm f4  100% crops at centre
35mm f4 100% crops at centre
35mm f4 100% crops at top right
35mm f4 100% crops at top right
35mm f4  100% crops at left
35mm f4 100% crops at left
35mm f4  100% crops at bottom right
35mm f4 100% crops at bottom right
g4/57/44657/3/91906871.UCf5CIjQ.jpg Canon 17-40 36mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 17-40 36mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 34mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 34mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 32mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 32mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 35L 35mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 35L 35mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 35mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 35mm at f8 (warning: full size)
35mm f8 100% crops at centre
35mm f8 100% crops at centre
35mm f8 100% crops at top right
35mm f8 100% crops at top right
35mm f8 100% crops at left
35mm f8 100% crops at left
o6/57/44657/1/92148107.IvgXQFhi.fill1.jpg
g4/57/44657/3/92155896.9vma433s.jpg Canon 24-70 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 70-200 70mm at f4(warning: full size)
Canon 70-200 70mm at f4(warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 70mm at f4 (warning: full size)
70mm f4 100% crops at centre
70mm f4 100% crops at centre
70mm f4 100% crops at top right
70mm f4 100% crops at top right
70mm f4 100% crops at top left
70mm f4 100% crops at top left
70mm f4 100% crops at bottom left
70mm f4 100% crops at bottom left
o6/57/44657/1/92148110.orvL1H1j.fill3.jpg
g4/57/44657/3/92155834.viTgigPS.jpg Canon 24-70 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-70 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 24-105 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 70-200 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 70-200 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
Canon 28-135 70mm at f8 (warning: full size)
70mm f8 100% crops at centre
70mm f8 100% crops at centre
70mm f8 100% crops at top right
70mm f8 100% crops at top right
70mm f8 100% crops at top left
70mm f8 100% crops at top left