photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery One: Travel Abstractions -- Unlimited Thought > Dilemma, Pingyao, China, 2007
previous | next
14-SEP-2007

Dilemma, Pingyao, China, 2007

This image represents the dilemma of Pingao itself. It is one of the few cities left on earth enclosed by its original walls. It has been off the tourist track until now, but crowds are growing in this UNESCO World Heritage city. Will Pingyao gradually change itself into a historical theme park for the sake of tourism? Or will it carefully preserve its treasures in a less flashy way in order to ultimately offer a more accurate and more useful vision of its past to its visitors? I try to ask such questions with this image. I abstract one of the city’s famous towers as a silhouette. At first glance it seems to be just another pagoda-like building. Yet by abstracting it in this way, I call attention to the incongruous lights that bristle along the building’s edges. The lights, when illuminated, will create an entirely different Pingyao. A tourist’s city, rather than a cultural treasure. Yet in this image, they are not yet turned on, leaving us to wonder if perhaps there is a better way for Pingyao to offer its history to the world?

Leica V-Lux 1
1/1300s f/11.0 at 68.8mm iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis04-Feb-2009 21:38
This image is all about the relationship of negative space to content -- the jagged edges created by the lights strung on the buildings are the whole point of the picture. The golden sky becomes the canvas for that idea. Thanks, Shawn, for pointing this out.
Guest 04-Feb-2009 20:04
I like the jagged edges of the silhouetted items in this image. I also like the loss of scale in this image. The negative space seems to capture the attention of my eyes but it seems to work well in this case.
Phil Douglis06-Feb-2008 19:50
Good point, Suzy -- these lights may also be intended as an expression of local pride in their own history, even if it means distorting it. Ultimately, by making this image, I ask my viewers to consider such things as this. Expressive images are at their best when they can ask questions and demand answers from their viewers.
Suzy Walker-Toye06-Feb-2008 17:25
I’m not sure if this applies to this place (although possibly it does from what you’ve said about the community) but has anyone considered that all the ‘Christmas-tree’ lights may not be just for the benefit of the tourists? When we were in Phnom Penn in Cambodia we had a local guide and when questioned why their very sacred and beloved pagoda was light up in such a gaudy way he said (without a trace of sarcasm) that it was so people could see it from far away. They are very proud of their heritage and this is there was of enjoying it (and of course showing it off). It’s quite possible that the locals would have put the lights up even if there were no tourists too see.

Great idea for an image/talking point though.
Phil Douglis20-Jan-2008 22:00
Glad your mathematical mind combined with your rich imagination to enjoy the degree of abstraction in this image, Barry. Silhouettes do have the power to kick imaginations into high gear. (See my new gallery devoted entirely to the silhouette as photographic expression. It's athttp://www.pbase.com/pnd1/silhouettes ) I particularly appreciate your comment on the colored background -- it adds so much to this scene. It would not work nearly as well as a black and white picture.
Barry S Moore20-Jan-2008 10:40
Being of a mathematical mind on first inspect I thought I saw a fractal chaos image. the Serpents tails on the building on the Left draw my eyes. On further inspection I think I see the profile of a war ship about to be eaten by a sea monster. Such is the power of sillouettes. Imagination runs riot. The background orange/pink is gorgeous and breaks the picture out of the black and white only norm.
Phil Douglis17-Oct-2007 18:24
Thanks, Tim, for this interpretation. I can see where your idea comes from: the community is symbolized by the tower, while each person clings to the edge of it, forming a web of complexity.
Tim May17-Oct-2007 16:54
The bristling lights along the edge of the towers has a different meaning for me. I see them as representing the people of Pingyao, of the complex lives that are lived in this heritage city.
Phil Douglis28-Sep-2007 01:52
You have asked the same questions I have, Patricia. The answer is probably Pingyao itself. It is small city with great treasures, and just now beginning to realize the potential economic impact of tourism. I hope they do not kill the goose that laid the golden egg by making a Thankgiving turkey out of it! I did not see much of Pingyao at night, but I imagine these gates must look like Christmas trees. Why not use tasteful flood lights instead?
Patricia Lay-Dorsey28-Sep-2007 01:39
Like a turkey trussed for an American Thanksgiving dinner, the building on the left is overstuffed. Especially as compared to its more natural companion on the right. By showing these buildings in silhouette you make us ask questions that a more colorful, detailed presentation would not. Questions like Why? Why garnish an already beautiful building with lights? Why not leave it in the ancient form that has served it well for centuries? For whom are they doing this? Is this really what tourists like? To see history lit up like a christmas tree?

Artistically, this image makes me think of shadow puppets, one dimensional and created to be seen from only one perspective. Such an effective presentation to make your point, Phil.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment