photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Twenty Eight: Using symbols and metaphors to express meaning > Touching the hero, The Grand Place, Brussels, Belgium, 2005
previous | next
09-JUN-2005

Touching the hero, The Grand Place, Brussels, Belgium, 2005

Everard 't Serclaes was killed defending Brussels in the 14th century. For the last few hundred years visitors to the city's Grand Place have touched the shiny bronze arm and hand of his recumbent statue for good luck. I photographed numerous visitors touching the monument, but all of the images were more descriptive than expressive. The reason: lack of symbolization. Finally a couple of kids reached for that bronze hand simultaneously, clasping them all together on the monuments hand in a virtual embrace. I abstracted this scene by lifting my camera to include just the wrists and hands of the kids, and cropping out the rest of them. Abstraction often produces symbolism and metaphor. The laying on of hands is an ancient symbol of blessing, faith, and luck. The flowing bronze corpse of Everard’t Serclaes symbolizes mourning, the eager hands of young children express enthusiasm and camaraderie. A contradiction? Perhaps. But also a union of opposites: past and present, life and death, a bad break and the prospect of good fortune.

Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ20
1/100s f/3.7 at 31.3mm iso80 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis17-Apr-2006 07:02
Your poetry always enhances my imagery, Likyin. We make a good team.
Guest 02-Apr-2006 07:06
Don't go, or, take us with you.
No, I am too tired, got to go, and leave me alone ...
Life will not be the same without you!
Well, good luck, kids ...

All the grinning was cropped, bitterness and stress were left. We need sculptures, because even the greatest soul need a container to hold dialogues.
Phil Douglis01-Mar-2006 06:52
Thanks, Xin -- you have helped illuminate this image for me. You have linked incongruity with irony -- it is indeed ironic that one achieves adoration and fame by dying, and that is what this image is actually all about. Thank you for stressing the subplot here -- it is really the point of the entire image.
Sheena Xin Liu01-Mar-2006 05:20
Beautiful composition. I see dramatic incongruity between the grandeur of the hero and the fervor of the followers....I see it as an irony because people are frenzied about a dead statue, while the hero may not be really adored when he was alive...
Phil Douglis10-Aug-2005 04:52
Thanks, Philip. This is one of the images that reminds me why I'm in photography. The combined hands, their placement on statue, and yes, even that watch, combine to provide a moment of spontaneous meaning through symbolization.
Guest 10-Aug-2005 04:19
Amazing shot. Your explanation afirmed what I saw when I first looked at the image.
Phil Douglis09-Aug-2005 16:29
Glad you mention the watch, Zandra. I like it, because it speaks of today, while the statue speaks of yesterday. Yet today still honors the traditions that have come down to us from yesterday. And that makes it timeless in a way, doesn't it? Glad you liked this image, Zandra -- it tells many different stories, as both you and Kal bring out.
Guest 09-Aug-2005 15:41
I find thi to be a great example of "Abstraction does the trick". I can very well see that tis would not have the same impact shoudl we have sen teh faces of those people touching the statue. You say in your note they are children but tehr is no way for us to tell wheter they are children or adults, men or women. They are universal. One thing which bothers me is the clock on his vrist. It puts the image in to a particular ear. It is a modern watch, a modern time. Without it the image would have been time less and spoken even stronger about mns quest for blessing, faith, luck, answers and hopes...Without the watch, i wonder what this would tell us if it was in B&W/Sepia. Somehoe i don't think that woudl work in this image. Even though Sepia can make it feel more timeless to much details woudl go lost and so it would loose its origonal mening. The hands woudl not be so visible.Yeat agai that proves the point that abstracting it the way you did was teh right choise in order to add that touch of human value. To me this speks of hope, or should i say prayres of hope and blessing and yet again it is the hands that does it. I find this to be one of my favorite pictures in this gallery and one which i learn great lessons from.
Phil Douglis03-Jul-2005 04:21
Thanks, Kal, for bringing your personal experience with this ritual to bear upon this image. You are right -- the direction of the hand touch or swipe makes a huge difference. Most people just reach out and touch the bronze. Their hands did not speak -- they were simply following, as you said, the herd. But these young kids had to reach up to touch it, and they decided they would do it together. There is indeed a touch of reverence here, but more than that, there is an expression of unity. I think these kids were too shy to touch the statue individually. But together, as comrades, they could do it forcefully. That's why this moment was so much more expressive. The acts of simultaneously touching and sharing the statue from below, rather than from above, says it all. To make it work even more effectively as symbolism, I abstracted the image by including only the hands in the frame.
Kal Khogali03-Jul-2005 03:49
Phil, many a time I brought visitors here to touch this bronze. Some did it with faith, others with amusement, and "Herd Instinct". I always remember wondering about the contrast between the dark aged bronze and the shiny bronze, kept in it's original form from the touching of peoples hands (more of a wipe normally actually!). This statue was always about renewal for me, how strange that the touch of a hand in reverence was enough to keep this bronze looking new, and perhaps also it's message. Without the hands, this image would mean someting personally to me, because you capture the difference between shiny and tarnished bronze well, but with the abstracted hands you make the image universal, because now viewers may understand thedifferences in the bronze. I also note that the hands rising from above raise this bronze to a thing of reverence, not the same if the hands came from any other direction.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment