photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery One: Travel Abstractions -- Unlimited Thought > Door Carving, Royal Palace, Mandalay, Myanmar, 2005
previous | next

Door Carving, Royal Palace, Mandalay, Myanmar, 2005

Mandalay's Shwe Nandaw Monastery was at one time part of the Royal Palace of Mindon, the King of Burma from 1853-1878. It is famous for its intricate woodcarvings. The entire monastery was once gold plated, inside and out. Rather than try to show the entire façade of the palace itself, which would be little more than a postcard photograph, I bring the entire palace down to this single carving – a fascinating detail on one of the palace’s teak doors. The process of symbolizing a larger entity through one small detail is, in itself, an act of abstraction. Yet, so too is this photograph. I used my spot meter to expose for the most brilliant of the highlights falling on the door from the late afternoon sun. I let everything else go black. The figure, which appears to be in a fighting mood, has raised its arm as it peers into the blackness below. He seems to still be rallying Mindon’s armies long after they have passed into history. This carving is but a small detail of a larger door, which is, in turn, is only a small part of a large building. And now we look at the smallest of detail within that carving itself, trying to take ourselves back to another time and another place. What we are doing here, of course, is abstracting the abstraction, and trying in the process to get as close as we can to the essence of the place.


other sizes: small medium large original auto
share
Phil Douglis16-Jun-2007 05:34
I like the way you see the irony of implied motion within an object that has known "centuries of stillness," Sun Han.
Guest 16-Jun-2007 04:15
most sensual one in this gallery, owe to the shadow caused by the interplay of light and the alive ancient carving of foliage and figure. great motion in the artefact itself spite of the years old stillness
Phil Douglis13-Sep-2006 22:09
You and I are essence seekers, Jenene. To be able to recognize the essence of a place when you see it, and then photograph it in a way that expresses that essence to others, is the ultimate challenge of travel photography. I am happy that this image works on both of those levels for you, Jenene.
JSWaters13-Sep-2006 19:18
This images resonates so personally with me, Phil. One of the benefits of living as an expatriate in Asia, was traveling on an intimate level to neighboring countries. I was always fascinated by the carvings above/on doorways, entrances, shrines, etc. and their meaning. Sometimes mystical, or in this case, storytelling, they are always and indicator of the essence of that culture. You've captured and portrayed that essence well here. It's making me nostalgic for a trip back.
Jenene
Annie J20-Jul-2006 23:17
This is true Phil, I hadn't really thought about the headwear. It doesn't necessarily have to BE the king though, it just (to me anyways) reflects the notion of the weight of so much on his shoulders, much as a ruler would feel I would think...
Phil Douglis20-Jul-2006 22:52
I like your interpretation, Annie. I would like to think that this is a portrayal of King Mindon, bearing the weight of governance upon his shoulders. However the cap seems to be that of a soldier or functionary -- would not a King wear a royal headress, such as a crown?
Annie J20-Jul-2006 22:37
The man in this carving seems like he has a great weight on his shoulders (I think it is the angle and the wood behind him which he seems to be holding up), much as I would imagine a leader would when ruling his country, I think you did well in capturing the essence of the building in this one.
Phil Douglis20-Oct-2005 01:01
Thank you, Russ. I welcome you to join the many students who are learning from these examples of expressive travel photography and participating in an interactive dialog with me here in the comments section. You will learn as much from these comments, and my responses to them, as you will from my images. I am delighted that you have recognized the essence of my teaching philosophy with this comment. Less can indeed often be more! I am thrilled that you can see the value of this way of seeing, as opposed to trying to literally describe the whole subject. And I look forward to hearing from you often.
Russ Sprouse 20-Oct-2005 00:30
Phil:

As I told you in a private email, I am extremely excited to discover your site as a learning resource. I have been a photographer for decades and have developed a reasonable level of technical expertise, but I have never been able to create a framework that would allow consistent and thoughtful "expression." My photos tend to be "literal" even when I am able to achieve something "artistic."

This image illustrates how different your methods are that my own. In this situation, I would have searched for the opportunity to capture as much detail as possible, and a "complete" representation of the site or subject. I would have taken overall pictures of the building, and perhaps a well-lit picture of one of the carved doors, trying to "capture" the "whole" of it. Instead, you look for the "essence," foregoing the need to preserve all the detail and instead creating an image that communicates the feeling, the "essence" of the experience.

-- Russ
Phil Douglis28-Aug-2005 18:16
Welcome to my site, Kostas. These images are here for you to learn from. So, too, is the dialogue that I have with my viewers. I hope that photographers of all levels, from beginners onward, can learn from these examples. I welcome your participation in my cyberbook, and hope that when you get your camera and begin to practice what I am teaching you, that you will post your own pictures here on pbase so that all of us can help you grow.
Kostas Fotiadis 28-Aug-2005 16:23
Hello Phil.,
I come from far away, sunshine Greece and found this site accidentally. My English are no good, so it was hard for me to understand the meaning of abstraction in a photo. Then one sentence opened my mind: "The process of symbolizing a larger entity through one small detail is, in itself, an act of abstraction." Needless to say that I am bellow the average beginner level and I am still trying to decide what cam to get since at the moment I am stucked to a compact Olympus. I don't think I will participate to the contest but I will keep reading your cyberbook and see how far it will get me.
Kind Regards,
Kostas
Phil Douglis22-Jul-2005 18:22
Thanks, Rod. I am delighted when you find images that make sense to you in my galleries. There really is no need for you, or for anyone, to understand and appreciate all of my abstractions. As an expressive photographer, my target is the imagination of the viewer. As you know, no two imaginations are alike. What stimulates my imagination might prove bewildering or uninteresting to yours. I realize this when I make my abstractions. I am well aware that my images will not excite every imagination that comes to them. But as a teacher of photographic expression, I feel an obligation to offer my viewers a range of examples of abstraction that might be useful as a learning resource. Even if you can't relate to a particular image, by discovering how and why others might find value in it, you may be able to gradually absorb some valuable insights that you can apply to your own imagery.
Guest 22-Jul-2005 14:32
I like how you used the light. I cannot say I understand most of your abstract photos, but this one makes perfect sense to me :)
Phil Douglis03-Jun-2005 21:04
Thanks, April. Although I post this image here as an example of abstraction used to symbolize a larger subject by bringing it down to a single expressive detail, it is the play of light and shadow, as you say, that brings this detail its sense of dimensionality, and the diagonal composition implies energy and movement.
Guest 03-Jun-2005 20:58
VERY nice. i love your composition and play with light.
Phil Douglis08-Mar-2005 22:58
Thanks, Clara. Small things can tell large stories.
Guest 08-Mar-2005 16:33
Wonderful detail/abstraction of a piece of history and art. Yes once again, shadow is a great tool for abstracting meanings.
Phil Douglis05-Mar-2005 00:20
Good question, Tim. I was fully aware of all that I mentioned here well before i took this picture. In Burma, unlike Laos, I was fortunate to be working with a private guide whose sole purpose at this moment was expediting my images. Her personal knowledge of this place was vast and deep. She spoke excellent English, and responded intelligently to every question I asked her. As we approached this fantastic structure, she was telling me about all that I mention in this caption, so that I could look for subject matter that would define the essence of what I was seeing. I kept questioning her, narrowing my focus, until she showed me the incredible carvings on the doors. I had to walk around the entire structure to find the door that most eloquently reflected the late afternoon light. And on that door was this figure. And so I made this image. Later, I double checked all of my facts in my Burma guidebook, which was an invaluable reference, since it put everything into context. Good question, and thanks for asking it, Tim.
Tim May04-Mar-2005 19:59
Before I read your commentary on the image I had come up with my own of the transition of history from the light of the present to the darkened memory of the past. I also feel it in what little I know of current Myanmarian history - battles still rage.
I am curious though if you are aware of all that you mention in your caption as you take the image, or is your way of seeing so ingrained in you by this time that you don't consciously think what you are doing, or do you bring your understanding to it as you edit and select?
Phil Douglis27-Feb-2005 20:22
Thanks. You have put me in very good company, Mo. Rembrandt and Steve McCurry are the stuff of genius. To have one of my pictures mentioned in connection with either or both is humbling, to put it mildly.
monique jansen27-Feb-2005 08:46
A Rembrandt like play with light and shadow. Also reminds me of many photos of Steve McCurry (photographer of the Afghan girl).
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment