photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment
Phil Douglis | all galleries >> Galleries >> Gallery Twenty Two: Black and white travel photography – making less into more > In the Halls of Maha Muni, Mandalay, Myanmar, 2005
previous | next
06-FEB-2005

In the Halls of Maha Muni, Mandalay, Myanmar, 2005

Mandalay's most important religious structure is the incredible Maha Muni Pagoda. Built in 1874, this glittering Burmese temple complex houses a gold plated image of Buddha that draws pilgrims from all over the world. More interesting to me, however, was the life that goes on within the walls of the Maha Muni. It is a labyrinth of corridors, linking courtyards, shops, and religious shrines. Here, a little boy carries his young brother on his back as he scurries through one of them. They are probably the children of one of its many shopkeepers.

This is basically an example of street photography. (See Gallery Sixteen for more on this subject.) Street photography often lends itself to black and white imagery, because of its hard-edged grittiness. In color, even sad things can sometimes be made to look at least somewhat pleasant. The color version of this image soothes the loneliness of these children, and works very well as an expressive travel image, showing off both the beauty and reality of the Maha Muni. You can see it in color in my travel article on Myanmar posted at: http://www.worldisround.com/articles/139134/photo97.html

As well as it worked in color, I think this image works even more forcefully and memorably as a gritty black and white “street shot.” Once I’ve taken away the warmth of those red and gold walls, this little boy and his brother suddenly become more forlorn and vulnerable. They are trapped between what now become two grim black walls on each side of the image (they used to be brown). They represent forces seemingly beyond the understanding of this uncomprehending child with a blurred foot and sleeping burden on his back. He now must dodge menacing figures while navigating a labyrinth of cold, tiled corridors, instead of strolling through that warm and welcoming gilded world of the Maha Muni we saw in the color version.

Panasonic Lumix DMC-FZ20
1/20s f/2.8 at 17.2mm iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
previous | next
share
Phil Douglis30-Sep-2005 18:56
I don't see you disagreeing with Vera on this - you are simply taking another view of the same general feeling that black and white generates: vulnerability.
Guest 30-Sep-2005 15:09
I should also mention the items carried by the bogey man makes me wonder what is in his bag? its as if the kids have a choice., go with religion, or go with what the bogey man has
Guest 30-Sep-2005 15:08
Additionally, it seems the kids are going towards the other chap carrying some items. Its' as if he represents some sort of safe haven found in religion. Will the kid and the little brother get there in time, or will that bogey man get them first? This is my instinctive impression. I really like this photo, as it gave me a sense of drama
Guest 30-Sep-2005 15:05
Wow, this is one of the times V and I do not see eye to eye. When I see the color version, I agree with her about the distractions. When I see the BW, I immediately see a predator stalking little kids. The abstracted man is like a bogey man (spelling?) hiding in the shadows and stalking unsuspecting kids, because his attention is towards them (unlike the other abstracted figure walking away from them). It's as if his attention is on the kids, just as ours is, only in bw, shadowing, and abstraction he's more monsterous.
Phil Douglis09-Mar-2005 05:48
Vera, you have taken my interpretation of this black and white version and dramatically extended its reach by not only seeing the vulnerability of these young boys, but also projecting a life-scenario for them well into the future. You show me that my decision to turn this beautiful color image into stark black and white was a wise one. The Maha Muni is a lovely place, but in black and white its long corridors become fraught with dangers. Thanks, Vera, for this interpretation. You are among the finest black and white photographers on pbase -- you know when to use color, and when to remove it. To offer your views on this and other of my black and white examples, is a precious asset.
Guest 09-Mar-2005 05:00
In the colour version, I was too distracted by the colourful, cheerful walls to feel for the two children. Here in b&w, my attention is immediately drawn to them. What appears in my mind is this sad story of two kids born in a poor family. Their parents are too busy working to take care of them. So they are very vulnerable to all sorts of danger -- including the abduction by strangers such as the two giant dark figures on the right. So the elder brother, carrying his little bro, hurries away from the potential danger. Right now he has the burden of taking care of his little brother; but probably in a few years, he will have a much greater burden of earning money to support his family, perhaps by working hard labour like the man on the left. v.
Type your message and click Add Comment
It is best to login or register first but you may post as a guest.
Enter an optional name and contact email address. Name
Name Email
help private comment