Judges Comments

A good creative image. The composition is very different and grabs the viewer's attention. The muted tones and the choice of photo borders give the impression of age. The vignette works well.
What would work well with this image, would be to turn it into a mono. You can do it in Camera Raw / Bridge using 2 clicks. Click on BW and then adjust the black slider. It makes the image really pop.
One nitpick - At the bottom of the top picture, just above the red roof, the white edge of the photograph is cutting the bronze tree into two. This should be cloned out.