photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
Canon Image Challenge | all galleries >> CIC 216: Shake, Rattle & Roll >> Exhibition > Common Carp
previous | next
02-Apr-2021 Mick66

Common Carp

I caught this beauty today, about 8lb. Is he/she shaken, rattled or just rolling with it? I think just happy it knows it is going back in the water soon, it did, and what a wonderful condition it is in.
It's from a private lake with only about 50 members.

Canon EOS Rebel T7
1/400s f/6.3 at 55.0mm iso400 full exif

other sizes: small medium large original auto
comment
Canon Image Challenge16-Apr-2021 12:05
Hey Traveller I don’t know of many people that actually enjoy eating carp. If you ate carp it was more of a act of desperation rather than desire. I propose maybe you’re confusing carp and trout. Paul
Canon Image Challenge15-Apr-2021 02:59
Mick,
You would love fishing in the US. I came from Minnesota, land of 10,000 lakes.
Fishing was generally controlled, however, so that the fish population remained healthy.
There was a fishing season, you needed a license, and there was a limit on the size and number of the kind of fish you could catch and keep. The rest you could release back into the lake; so called catch and release.
Most, if not all states, have similar regulations.

Jim
Canon Image Challenge14-Apr-2021 17:41
Traveller. The way it works here... These fish are not wild, they are farmed and then purchased by land owners to stock their lakes and stretches of river/canal.
They are property, which is the reason for catch and release. It would be theft to take them.
We pay annual/season or day tickets to fish them for sport all across the UK. I assume, from your incredible need to eat it, fishing is regarded as hunting.

I think you can take small fish from wild stretches from the river, but don't quote me on that. Although, I doubt there are many wild stretches left.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge14-Apr-2021 02:01
I will say that this is a beautiful looking fish....I sense that it is longing to be in my oven at 425 degrees....soft tasty flesh. (that sounds bad...lol) Traveller
Canon Image Challenge13-Apr-2021 10:55
Let's hear your best fish story, T.

Dave
Canon Image Challenge13-Apr-2021 01:39
I guess I don't get catch and release...it has been a while since I've fished, ocean or river, but....if I caught it, I ate it, (or if it were a 25lb tuna, cut it into sections for freezing).

No, if I catch you, you'll be cleaned and eaten.

Best Wishes, Traveller
Canon Image Challenge08-Apr-2021 09:53
Dave. No, I don't mind, I'm not offended. I probably worded it wrong.
I like to be a thinking angler and outwit the tough to get and have a semi lazy/unhectic day.
But some days I feel the want for action and I'll go to a lake that is better stocked.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge08-Apr-2021 02:26
Having lived and fished (a little) in both Michigan and Minnesota, I have always regarded fishing as a gamble. I generally went for the fun of peacefully drifting on the water and being with whoever was in the boat with me; though I was often alone..

Jim
Canon Image Challenge08-Apr-2021 01:59
If you don't mind my saying so, Mick, that sounds like how a gambler would be likely to think.

Dave
Canon Image Challenge07-Apr-2021 18:29
Exactly Dave. I'd rather have the pleasure knowing I played a part in the game.

Although I must admit, if I've suffered many consecutive days of catching next to none, I will go to a more prolific venue to get it out my system.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge07-Apr-2021 14:33
Fishing with a guaranteed catch? Where’s the challenge in that?

Dave
Canon Image Challenge07-Apr-2021 09:19
Dave. Yes, it can take them until after they have spawned (usually in May) to start feeding from a hook bait.

A lot of people hate fishing for the carp there because the risk of a blank (catching nothing) is huge. There is a good stock of other fish that can be caught so you just have to bait and tackle up for those if you want more action. Alternatively, as I mentioned to Jim, I have other lakes I'm a member of that are more willing to get hooked. :-)

Mick
Canon Image Challenge07-Apr-2021 02:36
When you say "they haven't switched on in this lake yet", Mick, does that mean they're still in their torpid winter mode?

We have a small pond with goldfish (carp relatives), and they are slowly becoming more active. I started feeding them their spring/fall food about two weeks earlier than usual this year, just a little at first. No fishing. I've never even caught any using a net.

Dave
Canon Image Challenge06-Apr-2021 16:22
Here in UK it is dominantly catch and release, all rivers and most (99% I reckon) private lakes. It's only certain private lakes that specifically stock trout that you are allowed to take any away, and you are limited to only a couple as per their individual rules.

I think it holds a lot of weight, what you say, about the remaining ones being smart enough to avoid hook bait. This is close to what I believe about the lake I caught this fish. It doesn't get restocked, all the carp have been resident since it was dug out ~15 yrs ago. I believe the fish have enough natural resources too because it is well established and isn't overly stocked. Another place I fish is quite different, it gets regular restocking and there are plenty in there that they have to compete for food. They are suckers for hook bait.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge06-Apr-2021 13:49
Mick - I remember many years ago fishing in a small controlled lake like yours in Illinois that was monitored by the Department of Natural Resources. I think it was mostly catch and release, and you could keep one fish between certain limits. It was very difficult to catch a fish when I was there. But the DNR monitored the fish population, and said that the population remained stable over time. They concluded that the fish had "evolved" over the years where the ones remaining were "smart enough" not to bite on a hook. Their only solution to return it to a good lake to fish was to remove the current population and restock it with new fish. I don't recall what actually happened.

Jim
Canon Image Challenge06-Apr-2021 12:43
Dave. I don't know about the carp, but I was thinking a moment before I caught this fish that "fishing sucks". lol
They haven't switched on in this lake yet, not many are being caught, that was the only one I caught that day.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge06-Apr-2021 11:34
That fish appears to be thinking (do carp think?) "this sucks".

Dave
Canon Image Challenge05-Apr-2021 13:40
Don't you mean dumbest? lol

Mick
Canon Image Challenge05-Apr-2021 12:43
Carp have to be about the dummest fish on the planet.
Canon Image Challenge03-Apr-2021 12:20
Thank you both.

Mick
Canon Image Challenge03-Apr-2021 05:15
I agree - a good catch in many ways.

Jim
Sue Anne Rush03-Apr-2021 02:51
Excellent catch. V