photo sharing and upload picture albums photo forums search pictures popular photos photography help login
ctfchallenge | all galleries >> The Best of CTF Challenges >> Best of 2008 > 1st Place "Portrait gone wrong" By Cat
previous | next
30-DEC-2007 © Cat

1st Place "Portrait gone wrong" By Cat

23426

Rule broken: Never spook your subjects just before you take their portraits
Why it works: Sometimes you just HAVE to break the rules to see what happens :)
Note: No creature harmed during this portrait session



Seriously:
Rules broken: saturated color, correct color balance and Correct color fidelity (colors match those in the real world)
Why it works: Human feet do not have an orange glow :) and this water is not actually so blue. Its more of a pale green. But by breaking the rules and giving the feet an orange glow against the super saturated blue of the hot-tub (subject is doing a hand-stand) it pops, and looks interesting. The saturation boost of incorrect fidelity works with each other to create a nice contrast, there by practically going unnoticed, that it is broken.
There is also an argument of center comp vs rules of third in here, which one works and which one doesn't, but I am out of time and don't want to start another chapter with Lonnit again ;-) ;-) may be some other time ;-) I am headed for a New Years party :)

When the rules are broken and they work beautifully, one does not actually notice that they are broken, until they are pointed out. (IMHO) I think thats a lesson for all of us during this challenge. Nice challenge Lonnit and thanks for a good workout!

Canon EOS 20D ,Canon EF 24-70mm f/2.8L USM
1/400s f/7.1 at 70.0mm iso100 full exif

other sizes: small medium original auto
previous | next
comment | share
ctfchallenge01-Jan-2008 00:20
Oh, Cat, what a wonderful summation to the year and the challenge! Thank you so much. I'm glad you made it back in under the wire. You explain, beautifully why it works and why breaking the rules for good reason works so well. Thanks so much!!! ~ Lonnit
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 23:55
Thanks Debi, This is in a hot tub, and a candid. The water is too turbulent for ripples.
-Cat
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 23:53
Thanks K2 and Lonnit!
I added additional blue text.
-Cat
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 22:04
Hmm.. I think there's a common rule for portrait photography to make the model relax.. so the opposite behavious would be breaking that. But proportions, perspective and composition here tells me the rule wasn't actually broken ;) This is wayyy too good to not be meticulously rigged up for. Lovely moist heels btw. A splendid photo, and I like the location of the feet.. order in the bubbly chaos.. I find the contrast amusing.
-k2
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 21:03
Dang you, Cat! Ok, there's no rule about that!!! LOL! Please give a real rule and real justification. Maybe something about the centered subject, but that you kept teh feet on the upper and lower thirds line. I just hope you come up with it quickly b/c time is running out. This is an adorable shot! I will say, though, that it truly would have been better if the feet were at the right upper and lower interesections of thirds; I'm not thrilled with the centering. Love the colors adn the foam, the processing, and the fact that there is nothing superfluous in the scene! OH, those colors!!!! Is it a hot tub? Is the subject doing a handstand? Your timing couldn't have been this good to catch a dive! Tell us about the shot.~ Lonnit
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 20:21
Lol good centred composition too , Prob there should be some ripples around the feet- Debi
ctfchallenge31-Dec-2007 20:06
lol. I'll jot that rule down! Beautiful picture, lovely details and colors, and very funny too :)
-k2